Presented here are the results of a comparative trial on the
efficacy of three artemisinin-based combinations conducted
from May to October 2004, in Pool Province, Republic of Congo.
The main outcome was the proportion of cases of true treatment
success at day 28. Recrudescences were distinguished from
re-infections by PCR analysis. A total of 298 children of
6-59 months were randomized to receive either artesunate +
SP (AS+SP), artesunate + amodiaquine (AS+AQ) or artemether
+ lumefantrine (AL), of which 15 (5%) were lost to follow-up.
After 28 days, there were 21/85 (25%) recurrent parasitaemias
in the AS+SP group, 31/97 (32%) in the AS+AQ group and 13/100
(13%) in the AL group. The 28-day PCR-corrected cure rate
was 90.1% [95% CI 80.7-95.9] for AS+SP, 98.5% [95% CI 92.0-100]
for AS+AQ and 100% [95.8-100] for AL, thereby revealing a
weaker response to AS+SP than to AL (p = 0.003) and to AS+AQ
(p = 0.06). A potential bias was the fact that children treated
with AL were slightly older and in better clinical condition,
but logistic regression did not identify these as relevant
factors. There was no significant difference between groups
in fever and parasite clearance time, improvement of anaemia
and gametocyte carriage at day 28. No serious adverse events
were reported.
Considering the higher efficacy of AL as compared to AS+SP
and the relatively high proportion of cases with re-infections
in the AS+AQ group, we conclude that AL is clinically more
effective than AS+SP and AS+AQ in this area of the Republic
of Congo. Implementation of the recently chosen new national
first-line AS+AQ should be monitored closely. |